Tree surveys are often required as one of the technical reports to accompany a planning submission. In fact, many local planning authorities will refuse to register applications involving trees without a tree report to BS5837:2012. However, the report is more than just a list of trees. This is also not a task which can be undertaken as a desk-top exercise.
The starting point is an audit of the trees present. It is unlikely that all of the trees on a potential development site are worth retaining. There are four categories of suitability for retention. If a tree is not suitable for retention, then the report should explain this clearly, with details of why. The report is being written, in part, for the tree officer employed by the local planning authority, who will be expecting this detail. One of the aims of the survey is to find the treasures on a site and to highlight them.
Part of the survey process is establishing the size of each tree, both now and anticipated into the future. It then relates this to the proposed development, to identify any conflicts. This can range from trees in the way of access or in a place allocated for development. Sometimes, the tree is considered to be more important than the aspect of development proposed in its vicinity. Sometimes, we can put measures in place to minimise any damage to a tree.
Sometimes, we need to simply be realistic; an element of a proposal is not compatible with tree retention.
When there is no survey, trees which may enhance a development can be damaged or lost. If a survey is undertaken by someone with limited skills, there is a risk that measures to protect may be applied inappropriately.
The informed report will recognise that some trees are likely to be lost on most development sites. However, measures to mitigate will be proposed to reassure the officers and to ensure that the site is enhanced.
Common mistakes that can be made are, ‘I don’t need a report because there are no trees on my land’. Trees on a neighbour’s land, but affected by your proposal, may become a material factor. The informed tree survey and report will identify any issues with the trees and the proposed development and present solutions.
Case study one: Ms S wished to build her dream home on a small plot of land owned by a relative. Access was to be via the grass verge between the land and the public highway. Neighbours had been able to do this. The handful of trees to one side were not expected to be a problem; they were not significant, like oaks. She did not need a tree report. However, the proposals were not popular locally, and the local authority, which owned the trees, decided to retain them. The development could not proceed without their removal. Her dream was thwarted.
Mr. Williams wanted to extend his home. A tree in his neighbour’s garden was identified as a potential issue. Mr. Williams commissioned Cedarwood Tree Consultants to provide a tree survey which recognised the tree as being locally important and identified a solution which included installing decking between the tree and the extension, to avoid damaging the tree. The development was approved.
Mr. Jones wished to convert a redundant heritage building into a new office for his expanding business. This was only possible if a tree on the site, suitable for retention, was felled. Mr. Jones commissioned Cedarwood Tree Consultants to provide a tree survey and report. This explained the rationale behind Mr. Jones’ request, and provided mitigation measures including planting new trees. The planners appreciated the situation and approved the development.
When Mr. C was designing the layout of houses for his regeneration project, he assumed that all of the trees would need to be retained. We showed him how some were more important than others. A redesign of the layout in one part of the site, involving removal of several less suited trees enabled a more efficient use of the land. Plans for a water feature close to another tree were not pursued because it could have damaged that tree.
The tree survey identifies practical arrangements needed to ensure trees being retained are adequately protected. This includes space for storing materials, allocating space for trees where there is no construction activity and even priorities for works. It shows what is possible and realistic. For example, space is often needed for scaffolding. If space for this is limited, it may be better to install the scaffolding on the onside of a wall. By highlighting this in the report, those building the wall are informed and able to factor it in.
Sometimes, it is not realistic to retain an individual tree within a development site. It is better to be informed from the start about this than to spend time and money trying to retain the tree only to need to remove it later in the process, when costs may be higher.
Part of the process includes details of how trees are to be protected on a site with a plan and a Method Statement. This may specify the order of actions.
