The expert witness generally has an important role in the legal process. It is to advise the court on technical matters, in decision-making. The expert witness needs to be informed technically on the issues, and also to be familiar with the protocol within which they are working.
An expert witness may be instructed by a specific court to provide a report to inform their decision-making. They may be instructed by either party, or jointly. Regardless, the duty of the expert witness is to the court, and not to their client. This is different from other reports, which are often written in support of the instructing party.
The tree expert witness provides technical advice relating to trees. This includes investigating when trees fall over or shed branches, and this causes an injury. The tree expert will be called in to investigate what happened and whether the accident was foreseeable. This can include assessing the condition of the tree, whether there is evidence of decay, and if the landowner was taking reasonable precautions to ensure the safety of the tree.
Tree failure may cause damage to a property. In such a case, the tree expert may be called to assess whether the failure was foreseeable. If the claim is linked to insurance cover, then the presence of a tree report as part of the insurance policy being processed can be a factor in the appraisal; did the insurance company assess the presence of a tree before providing cover?
The tree expert can be asked to assess the merits of claims involving trees, including whether the sum being sought by a claimant is appropriate and proportionate. This can include investigating the extent of damage and the costs of mitigation works.
The tree expert can also be asked to explore issues relating to trees and possible structural damage. This can include whether damage has occurred and the best way to rectify. The expert’s work may require a simple desk-top assessment of evidence, or a site visit to appraise the situation.
The tree expert witness is required to remain independent and impartial throughout. Facts are presented as such, and opinion is clearly made and presented as such. This is one of the advantages with an expert witness report; it can enable a dispute to be resolved swiftly because all parties know that the opinion presented is independent.
Not all specialists presenting themselves as tree experts, and even as tree expert witnesses, are such. Part of the process of the tree expert, usually for the defendant, is to appraise the merits of any experts appointed by their client’s adversary. It is not uncommon for someone to be presented as an experienced specialist who lacks the skills, expertise and credentials. Credentials can include degrees in the relevant subject, including arboriculture, and evidence of training in the skills and protocol of the expert witness. The Cardiff University Expert Witness (CUEW) and membership of the Institute of Expert Witnesses (IWE) are examples of such training.
The expert witness report should present the situation, parties involved and the nature of the complaint. Facts should be presented as such, and opinion clearly presented accordingly within the report. An Executive Summary is beneficial to enable those reading the document to understand the key issues.
The role of the tree expert is to assess the evidence and provide informed observations and conclusions. This is not undertaken in an adversarial manner. When working for a claimant, it can be useful to start with a feasibility study to appraise the merits of a claim.
The expert witness proceeds on the basis of evidence presented. If there is new evidence, or an opinion changes, they are required to inform their client of this as soon as possible.
Often, the presence of an expert witness report in a claim is sufficient to resolve it. It can demonstrate that the party which has commissioned it is serious in the case. For a defendant, the receipt of an expert witness report, with the independence it conveys, is sufficient. If there is no case, the claimant will be informed and cease further proceedings. If there is a claim, the claimant can proceed with confidence.
When a claim is being progressed by legal professionals, such as barristers, the conclusions of an expert witness report are important in assessing the merits and the chances of a successful outcome.
When a claim has an expert witness for both sides, the experts are required to read each other’s report and identify areas of agreement and disagreement. This enables the matters to be considered by the court to be highlighted and be the focus of discussion.
A good expert witness report should enable a dispute to be resolved before it reaches the court. This happens in most cases. However, the tree expert witness knows that, should they be required, they may have their day in court. This can be demanding. Being cross-examined is a demanding experience. However, it is rewarding in ensuring that the court is able to make an informed decision.
