Trees are an important feature of our urban landscape, contributing much to our lives. They cool the air, provide shade, reduce air pollution, and bring nature to an otherwise harsh environment. However, sometimes, an individual tree can become unsafe. The owner of a tree has a Duty of Care to ensure trees within their care are maintained in a safe condition. How do we minimise liability and have a defendable tree management plan?
The chances of being injured by a falling branch or tree are low. Very low. In fact, you are more likely to win the lottery or to be struck by lightening that to be injured by a falling branch. And when an accident happens, it is usually something that could not have been foreseen. It could not have reasonably been prevented. Trees being blown over in a storm, for example. Trees are designed to resist the normal winds they face in normal conditions.
A key element of tree safety revolves around the landowner’s Duty of Care towards others and the ability to demonstrate that the Duty of Care has been met. The level of expectation is greater for a tree owned by a business than for one owned by a private individual.
One thing to appreciate is that some aspects of safety can be by identified by observing a tree. The skilled tree consultant can identify signs of safety concerns using a technique called Visual Tree Assessment (VTA). With this information, the tree consultant can identify where safety is an issue and works required.
Key elements of a tree risk assessment are demonstrating that you know where your trees are, their condition and any works needed. And that works recommended have been undertaken, depending on their importance and urgency. Having a tree which is not safe does not necessarily mean that work is needed. Factors in the risk assessment process include identifying where there is a target within influencing distance of a tree and the occupancy rate.
A target could be a property, a bus stop or a road. If a tree is unsafe but there is no target, then there may be no need for pruning or felling; if a branch drops, it is unlikely to cause an accident.
One of the options for tree safety and managing risks is to explore whether the target can be moved. This is easier for a target such as a bench, or even a bus stop by an important tree, where moving or placing a cover over it may be possible. Paths may be diverted.
It may be possible to prune a tree, removing a hazardous branch or reducing the weight of branches.
The person who does the inspection should have some degree of competence in survey trees for safety. If this is a tree in a private garden, the inspection can be undertaken by a lay person, someone with an interest in trees and gardening may have sufficient expertise. For trees on land owned by a business, which includes a property which is managed by a management company, the inspection should be undertaken by someone professionally qualified and experienced in this task.
Written records should be kept of the inspection, the date and the conclusions. If no work is required, this should be specified.
The frequency of inspection will depend on the setting. The only statutory guidance relates to highways trees and inspections on a five-year cycle. Some cases where a tree has caused an accident, and the courts have considered the situation, the need for more regular inspections has been cited. The general rule is that if the condition of a tree and the setting require more frequent inspection, then an annual or bi-annual inspection is often appropriate.
In places such as Kew Gardens and Westonbirt Arboretum, six-monthly inspections are used for individual trees which are important to the collection and also in settings with a high footfall.
The key ingredients for a defendable tree management plan are that the trees have been identified, surveyed for their condition and safety, with a written record of findings, and action for recommendations. Where a tree has caused an accident and these elements are in place, the approach is usually considered defendable.
